Hibernian: The John Hughes Revolution

Well October is already well-aired and it seems such a while since I saw the Hibs play. When I say ‘play’ I mean in the flesh – actually watching from the seats at good old Easter Road or elsewhere. Watching on the television – and these days via the Internet, while a handy substitute, does not really cut it for me personally. I’d rather watch one live game than twenty on a screen.

It’s been a summer of revision of course. Erstwhile hero and former manager Mixu Paatelainen has left the club to be replaced by John ‘Yogi’ Hughes and big John has brought with him from his years at Falkirk, a rather large new broom to the club.


I have to confess that in the past, John was never a man I would have chosen to run the team I love. There were things I appreciated about his style sure, but I was quite a fan of the perhaps more sophisticated approach of John Collins, though I’m certain there will be many dissenters with that view. The point is that I hoped for a similar ‘modern’ manager at the helm and John Hughes with his apparent, rough around the edges approach to the beautiful game and life in general didn’t seem to fit my criteria.

There were times when the former Hibs central defender appeared to relish rubbing up some of the Hibs support during his visits as Falkirk’s manager. I felt some of his antics were uncalled for at times, in spite of some goading by the Hibees support no doubt, and this reinforced my view of ‘never at Easter Road please.’

We should always give a man a fair chance though and I felt it an intriguing choice by Rod Petrie and the Hibs board in choosing the Leith man to take up the difficult reigns of what had become a slightly poisoned chalice after Collins and Paatelainen. Further, it’s interesting to note the changes that John had brought about in his short stay in the job so far.

Of course any manager will stand and fall by his team’s results on the field of play, and there have been some encouraging signs amidst a little unexpected mediocrity thus far. If I’d to produce a school report for the big man at this point, I’d offer a ‘Shows promise’ comment. As always, it pays to be patient if you’re a Hibby, and now is no different. There was initial criticism and some disquiet of Hughes for raiding his former club to boost Hibs’ ranks but I feel this is fairly normal behaviour for any manager moving clubs who has seem talent and promise within individuals of the group of players he has been working with day, day out. What has subsequently been more remarkable is the way the Hibernian board have decided to back Hughes’ judgment in his prospective signings. This was not the case, at least to the same degree, with the previous two managers.


Hibs’ John Hughes in pensive mood

Suddenly, Hibs appear to have more outright quality in the squad than prior. A quick look at some of the slightly bargain basement signings necessitated by John Collins just two years ago confirms this. Man for man, the Hibees appear to be stronger in most areas of the pitch, with the arguable exception of central defence – a situation which I am convinced will be addressed in the next transfer window. In recent times two relatively expensive and expansive additions to the squad in the shape of Anthony Stokes and Liam Miller have been added to the squad. These additions have augmented some successful squad embellishments as Kevin McBride, David Wotherspoon and Danny Galbraith. It remains to be seen how all of the new men will work out in the long term but the signs so far are healthy. Meantime the excellent past Mixu moves, paving the way for the return of former favourites Ian Murray and Derek Riordan are, and will, enhance the squad hugely. It all looks good if the team can marry their quality with a good work ethic. I’m sure this will happen under John Hughes – a man who always stressed the worth of an honest day’s toil.

The new manager has so far spent a lot of time and focus in the media. The big fellow is certainly never short of a word or two for the press, radio and TV. Some may even claim him verbose. What is apparent though is his honesty and transparency and that is heartening. I like to consider myself as something of a football purist and Hughes’ adherence to playing the game the ‘right’ way sits very well with my sensibilities, more power to him in that. It’s all the more surprising when one thinks back to John’s career in the famous old Green and White jersey as a no-nonsense centre half with his tales of ‘square goes’ and ‘getting it right up the Jambos’!

I have to say I’m heartened and warming to the man. Does it show? I think he’s the ‘real thing’ and a damned good fit for Hibernian Football Club. I’ll be watching for his progress with great interest over the coming months.

Persevere, John Hughes.

2 thoughts on “Hibernian: The John Hughes Revolution”

  1. Hi Stu. I was lucky enough to take in the league game against St Johnstone at ER while I was over in the UK recently. While it was nice to see the Hibees put on a 3-0 win for me it was absolutely no surprise to learn they got pumped out the League Cup by the same opposition 3 days later.

    Hibs were, frankly, pants, and if the Saints had had a finisher they would have been three up themselves by half-time, not two down. Stokes and Miller looked like good additions to the squad, no doubt, but some of the youngsters (and others old enough to expect better from) had all the ball control of a garage door. Zouma came on and trapped a 50 yard cross ball with one touch of his big toe just to accentuate the gulf between him and the rest.

    I don’t suppose that situation is any worse than it’s been for the last few years, but the fact that we are still sitting near the top of the table highlights the apalling standard of Scottish football at the moment. So I suppose we stand as good a chance as any of finishing in the Euro spots, though I dread to think what Latvia or Liechtenstein’s finest might do to us if we don’t improve on what I saw last month.

    Still, having said all that, it was great to see the Cabbage in the flesh, and for what it’s worth I reckon big Yogi is doing as good a job as anyone would in the circumstances, and probably with a bit more humour, man-management skills and PR nous than either of his predecessors had. If he beats the Yams in the first derby then he’ll buy a year’s goodwill from the fans too.

  2. Hi Fraser, I hope you enjoyed your recent European stay and that you both had a fine time back home.

    I’m going to trust your opinion there After that initial St. Johnstone game the messageboards were full of disgruntled Hibs punters and after winning 3-0 I couldn’t quite see why. More generally speaking I have to agree, I don’t think the standard of Scottish football has ever been lower than it is now.

    When the Hibs manager post came up last time I came out and proclaimed John Hughes a shoe-in for the job – irregardless of hat I thought of his qualities. I have to agree with you again in saying that he’s as good as anyone (that’s affordable). I think he’s decent fit considering everything.

    A derby win will make him a hero for a while for sure, and I certainly think he’s the man to get the team fired up for that (which we’ve seen in his playing days). The flip side of the coin is that three or four bad results will soon see the Easter Road ‘faithful’ shouting for his head.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: